the Culinary Temple Experience Reserve a Table Dine by the Seaside Charm of Mystic Plan Your Visit GREAT DINING EXPERIENCE Reserve a Table Explore Menu Ambience Cucina Pantheon Location Cucina Pantheon

The Story of
Cucina al Pantheon

Cucina Al Pantheon was born from a love of tradition, community, and gathering. We’ve created a space where Mystic locals feel at home and visitors are welcomed like family—a place as comforting as dining at your nonna’s table, yet elevated enough for life’s most meaningful celebrations. From casual dinners to anniversaries, our goal is to be part of the stories that bring people together.

Set inside Mystic’s historic 1931 granite bank, the Pantheon-inspired columns now frame a new kind of gathering place. Just as the Pantheon in Rome has welcomed people for centuries, we envision this as Mystic’s living room—where friends, families, and neighbors share meals, wine, and conversation. Every dish is crafted with intention, blending Italy’s finest ingredients with a curated wine and cocktail program, but most importantly, we aim to create memories that linger long after the last bite.

LOCALS HOUR:

Sunday, Monday, Wednesday, & Thursday, 3–5 PM

Get 50% off select items when seated in our bar area.
Perfect for after-work bites or an early dinner treat!

Authentic Italian Flavors,
Crafted with Passion

At Cucina Al Pantheon, our menu is a love letter to Italy — where tradition, simplicity, and quality come together beautifully. From silky handmade pastas to rich, slow-simmered sauces and perfectly seared entrées, every plate reflects Restauranteur Petrit Marku’s dedication to authentic Italian cuisine. Pair your meal with a curated wine or handcrafted cocktail and savor the flavors of Italy in every bite.

Starters

Antipasto

24 months aged san daniele Prosciutto, porchetta, speck, dry cured salami, Parmigiano, Pecorino Romano, artichokes, hot peppers, green olives, Giardiniera Vegetables

$28

Homemade Meatballs

100% grass-fed beef, Homemade Pomodoro sauce, Parmesan Cheese

$18

Fritto misto

Fried calamari, Shrimp, carrots, Zucchini, homemade marinara

$19

Mussels

PEI Mussels, garlic, hot peppers, marinara, with artisan crostini

$18

Shrimp Polenta

Grilled Shrimp, Polenta, Basil Pesto

$23

Salads

Organic Tomato Salad

Fresh Organic tomatoes, French cheese, kalamata olives, peppers, red onions, cucumbers, Extra virgin Olive Oil

$20

Caesar

Romain lettuce, shaved parmesan, croutons, homemade caesar dressing

$13

Burrata

Imported Burrata, Pistachio Pesto, Cherry Tomato, Basil, home made crostini

$16

Caprese Salad

Fresh Mozzarella cheese, organic tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze

$18

Wedge Salad

Crispy Bacon, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onions, Gorgonzola Cheese, Homemade Dressing

$16

Mixed Green Salad

Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Balsamic Vinaigrette

$12

Pasta

Frutti di Mare

scallops, Shrimp, Mussels, little neck Clams, calamari, Linguine, Homemade pomodoro sauce

$39

Tagliolini Bolognese

homemade USDA beef bolognese, fresh tagliolini, aged pecorino Romano

$30

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Homemade grass-Fed meatballs, marinara sauce, Fresh Parmesan

$29

Free Range Chicken Parmesan

Panko crusted chicken breast, Fresh Mozzarella, Spaghetti, marinara Sauce

$32

Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Crispy Pancetta, Homemade Vodka Sauce, Basil, Burrata Cheese

$32

Entrees

Homemade Melanzane

Thinly sliced layers of delicate eggplant, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, Basil, Homemade Marinara sauce

$29

Organic Bells & Evans Chicken

Slow-roasted bone-in chicken, mushroom parmesan risotto with a Rosemary jus

$39

Salmon Alla Griglia

Grilled Salmon with asparagus parmesan risotto Cheese

$34

Swordfish

vegetable couscous, Homemade Salsa Verde

$37

Prime Cut 8oz Filet Mignon

Allen Brothers USDA Beef, Yukon Gold Potatoes Au Gratin, Roasted Asparagus

$50

Prime Cut 16Oz Ribeye

Allen Brothers USDA beef, roasted potatoes, grilled seasonal vegetables

$59

Pizza

Plain

Fresh mozzarella cheese and homemade pomodoro sauce

$20

Margherita

Fresh sliced mozzarella, homemade pomodoro sauce, fresh basil

$23

4 Formaggi

Mozzarella, Brie, Gorgonzola, Parmigiano

$24

Bufala e Prosciutto

24 months aged san daniele Prosciutto, basil, Bufala mozzarella cheese, Pomodoro Sauce

$26

Diavola

Pepperoni, Pomodoro sauce, Mozzarella

$23

Capricciosa

Prosciutto cotto, mushrooms, artichokes, Pomodoro sauce, mozzarella,

$25

Pantheon

Speck, Mozzarella, Cherry tomatoes, crispy eggplant, pecorino, fresh basil

$26

Napoli

Pomodoro Sauce, Anchovies, Kalamata Olives, Oregano, Garlic, olive Oil

$22

Garden

Fresh mozzarella, pomodoro sauce, roasted peppers, zucchini, mushrooms

$24

Aperitivo

Verde Spritz

Vodka, elderflower, mint, lime, and Prosecco. our lush and refreshing garden in a glass.

$16

Aperol Tropicale

Clementine Aperol, lime, Prosecco, and pineapple foam. sunshine served in a glass.

$16

Negroni Di Pantheon

Malfy Gin, Campari, Carpano Antica bold and eternal like the pantheon in Italy.

$16

Espresso Del Museo

Vanilla vodka, chocolate bitters, fresh espresso. a masterpiece in motion.

$16

Bianca di Fumo

Mezcal, Campari, lime, grapefruit passion wrapped in fire and mist

$16

Dirty Martini

Bombay gin, dirty brine, olive air elegance with a wicked grin

$18

Tiramisu Martini

Vodka, Amaretto, creme de cacao, espresso Dessert and a nightcap in one luxurious sip

$18

Reviews

Jackson Mittleman profile picture
Jackson Mittleman
18:33 30 Nov 25
Had a great family meal here the night before Thanksgiving. Pizzas were excellent (especially the Pantheon pizza with crispy eggplant), pasta was delicious, and the meats and appetizers were also great. Emily was our waitress and she helped ensure we had a great evening. Highly recommend!
Marie Thomas profile picture
Marie Thomas
02:02 23 Nov 25
Service and food is outstanding. You truly feel like family. We started with the shrimp polenta which was delicious, accompanied by an espresso martini, tomato salad with huge chunks of feta and a pizza we shared between 3 people. Will definitely be back!
Photo from customer reviewPhoto from customer reviewPhoto from customer review
Awesome experience! From atmosphere,to service, to food,it was a 10/10 experience. The restaurant is beautiful inside and our servers Justin and Melissa, were fantastic, very attentive, personable and genuinely warm. They made us feel right at home. The bread alone is out of this world, fresh, homemade with clean ingredients. My husband and I shared a margarita pizza and chicken parmigiana entree and both were delicious. The food is truly authentic Italian food, and that's coming from Italian New Yorkers! We will definitely be back the next time we are in town!
Jack Morehouse profile picture
Jack Morehouse
03:09 16 Nov 25
The food and service were excellent.
Chris Lessa profile picture
Chris Lessa
21:44 14 Nov 25
What a great find food is absolutely delicious
Service perfect
Will definitely be back
Matty Vogel profile picture
Matty Vogel
01:48 11 Nov 25
WOW. Simply amazing food. Our waitress was great, thank you Melissa!
Dr. Holly Silva profile picture
Dr. Holly Silva
19:58 09 Nov 25
**BEST RESTAURANT IN MYSTIC**
Look no further-Cucina Al Pantheon is hands down the best restaurant in Mystic! It is no surprise this is Petrit's 3rd Italian restaurant in the area-he continues to impress with authentic Italian cuisine, exceptional service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. You'll leave already planning your next visit.
Douglas profile picture
Douglas
13:45 09 Nov 25
We took our 3rd set of friends here last night. We all loved the service and enjoyed the food very much. Everyone that works here is quite delightful! Highly recommend this restaurant!

Ambience & Elegance

More than a meal, an Italian journey. Step into our world where every detail tells the story of Italian elegance and hospitality.

Cucina Al Pantheon

Italian Cusine

Book a Table - Cucina al Pantheon

To reserve your table, please contact us using the details below — our team will be happy to assist you.

    Address

    54 W Main St, Mystic
    Connecticut 06355

    Hours

    Monday 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
    Tuesday CLOSED
    Wednesday 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
    Thursday 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
    Friday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
    Saturday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
    Sunday 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

    In the Heart of Mystic’s Foodie Capital

    You’ll find us at 54 West Main Street, just steps from Mystic’s shops, galleries, and waterfront views. Once a historic bank, our building now welcomes guests to one of Connecticut’s most breathtaking dining destinations.

    Come see why Mystic is the foodie capital of Connecticut — and why Cucina Al Pantheon has quickly become its crown jewel.